Critical darling or not, Inishmore disappoints
Friday, July 28th, 2006They say that, as a playwright, seeing a poor performance of your work is akin to watching your child being beaten. I can only imagine what it must feel like to be Martin McDonagh witnessing his baby, “The Lieutenant of Inishmore” being shaken to death in the hands of its inept caregivers.
The script itself is delightfully absurd and subtly sardonic, an opaque and effective satirisation of Ireland and the IRA, if not all terrorism in general. In the line “All this terror over a cat?!” the final word could be replaced by another noun (say, “oil,” for example) to aptly describe any war, modern or ancient. The writing style is dutifully influenced by Oscar Wilde, Samuel Beckett, and (dare I say it?) Stephen Fry. With its biting banter and buckets of blood, it has a “Waiting for Godot” meets “Kill Bill” quality that ought to be a recipe for a great time at the theatre. The special effects are the star of the show, with fantastic crimson splatters, creating comic-book imagery I never imagined possible in a live theatrical setting. I’m certainly glad I don’t have to clear that set at the end of each night.
The play begins to flag, however, in the first scene, when the actors start delivering their lines. They begin in hysterics, literally shrieking the text and continue in this vein until the lights dim and the deafening Irish drum jolts the audience back from the white noise of the aforementioned vocal devastation. The two main characters begin with their energy so high that they leave no room for development, and when they discover that their lives may be endangered by a mad Liberation Terrorist, it’s anti-climactic. How am I to believe they are any more afraid of death by evisceration than they are of the air they breathe? Every word is delivered with the same frantic fright, and each line is punched so strongly, begging the audience for a laugh, one almost expects a wink and a high hat to elicit crowd response.
The director and the actors could have done with a few hours watching “Keeping Up Appearances,” “As Time Goes By,” “Dr. Who,” and (dare I say it?) “A Bit of Fry and Laurie” for a better understanding of how to work with modern existential scripts. These are prime examples of absurd humor performed at its best: quiet and quick, subtle and sweet, poignant and powerful. Instead, we are left watching a stageful of Ralph Cramdens with no Alice to provide contrast. This is a sad example of good material that is misunderstood and overly played. I want my $50 and my 2 hours back.